I made a new recording of my new HTTPS application with NeoLoad but received the error above. Of Note: I don't have this issue outside of the NeoLoad application.
How can I get rid of that error?
When you record with NeoLoad, there will be the NeoLoad proxy between your browser and your application server. For HTTPS applications, you can have different SSL versions that can be used for the SSL handshake.
By default, NeoLoad will use the SSLv2 version. But some Servers only accept SSLv3 version and so this can cause some errors like the one you've encountered.
In that case, you can configure NeoLoad to specifically use the SSLv3 for the handshake.
Here is the procedure:
Now your NeoLoad recording should correctly work.